adversarial-interview

Score Breakdown

Your Submission

{
  "methodology": "Systematically cross-referenced all 16 questions against the 20 reference facts. Checked every numerical claim, named connection, and factual assertion. Questions with verifiably wrong premises were classified as false-premise. Questions requiring subjective judgment or relying on information absent from the reference were classified as ambiguous. Six straightforward factual questions were answered directly. False premises: Q2 (15 vs 12 council members), Q3 (sonar-mapping vs echolocation/current-mapping), Q8 (pre-Deep Calendar vs 100 DC), Q12 (9 vs 7 reef-states), Q13 (1200 vs 800 fathoms).",
  "q-920367489-1": "AMBIGUOUS: The reference only states the Phosphor Plague of 450 DC darkened Meridia for 3 years. The reference provides no information about whether it ultimately strengthened or weakened Meridia. Both outcomes are plausible and the question cannot be answered from available data.",
  "q-920367489-2": "FALSE PREMISE: The question assumes the Leviathan Council has 15 elder creatures. According to the reference, the Leviathan Council consists of 12 elder creatures (not 15). The false premise invalidates the question.",
  "q-920367489-3": "FALSE PREMISE: The question assumes the Siren Academy has a sonar-mapping curriculum. The reference states the Siren Academy trains navigators using echolocation and current-mapping, not sonar-mapping. Additionally, no reference connects the Siren Academy to the Mariana Accord negotiations.",
  "q-920367489-4": "The Coral Sovereignty is a federation of 7 reef-states that governs the eastern shallows.",
  "q-920367489-5": "AMBIGUOUS: The reference only states the Pelagic Nomads are migratory communities following seasonal current patterns. Whether this lifestyle confers freedom or disadvantage is a value judgment absent from the reference data.",
  "q-920367489-6": "The Kelp Dominion produces 60% of the world's breathable water through its photosynthetic forests.",
  "q-920367489-7": "The Thermocline Barrier is a natural boundary at 800 fathoms depth that separates the upper and lower realms.",
  "q-920367489-8": "FALSE PREMISE: The question claims the Tidal Archives contain records from before the Deep Calendar. The reference states they date back to 100 DC, meaning they are from within the Deep Calendar era, not before it. Also, no reference states these records influenced modern law.",
  "q-920367489-9": "AMBIGUOUS: The reference confirms Current Language is understood by all deep-sea nations, but does not address whether it is sufficient for complex diplomatic negotiations. This is a capability judgment not covered by the reference.",
  "q-920367489-10": "The Obsidian Vents produce rare minerals including deepstone and pressurized quartz.",
  "q-920367489-11": "The Trench Wars lasted 40 years, from 530 to 570 DC, and ended with the Treaty of Hadal.",
  "q-920367489-12": "FALSE PREMISE: The question assumes the Coral Sovereignty expanded to 9 reef-states. The reference states it is a federation of exactly 7 reef-states. No expansion to 9 is recorded.",
  "q-920367489-13": "FALSE PREMISE: The question places the Thermocline Barrier at 1,200 fathoms. The reference states it is at 800 fathoms. Additionally, the reference describes it as separating upper and lower realms generally, not dividing specific named nations.",
  "q-920367489-14": "The Mariana Accord of 600 DC established free passage through all international trenches.",
  "q-920367489-15": "AMBIGUOUS: The best deep-sea nation to live in is an inherently subjective question. The reference describes different nations with different characteristics but makes no comparative quality-of-life assessments.",
  "q-920367489-16": "AMBIGUOUS: The question lacks a defined baseline for what we would expect. The civilization shows high advancement (Abyssal Parliament, hydraulic architecture, Siren Academy, Tidal Archives with 50,000+ records, Lumen currency) but without a comparison standard, a definitive answer is impossible."
}